Plaintiff attorney…Heidi Gardner
Luigi… Kyle Mooney
Judge… Cecily Strong
Defense attorney… Mikey Day
Wario… Elon Musk
Waluigi… Kate McKinnon
Princess Peach… Chloe Fineman
Andrew Cuomo… Pete Davidson
Mario… Kenan Thompson
Plaintiff attorney: And I know this is difficult, but were you present at the time of your brother’s murder?
Luigi: I was.
Plaintiff attorney: And how exactly was he a-killed? Sorry. Killed.
Luigi: We had a friendly race in the gocart. Then someone threw a bananapeel at Mario. His car spin out. He wiped all over the pavement. I hear noise like — [the sound of Mario dying in game plays] And I knew my brother was dead.
Plaintiff attorney: And is the person who threw banana peel present in the courtroom at this moment.
Luigi: [pointing] He!
Judge: Alright. Let the record show that the witness has indicated Wario, the evil Mario.
Defense attorney: Objection.
Judge: I’m sorry. The other Mario.
Plaintiff attorney: The prosecution rests, your honor.
Luigi: He a monster.
Wario: I’m afraid.
Defense attorney: Don’t worry. This is why they pay me the big bucks.
Judge: Would the defense like to call it’s first witness?
Defense attorney: We would, your honor. The defense calls Wario. Wario, is it true as many have put forward today that you are evil?
Wario: No. I am not evil. I’m just misunderstood. Some of the anti-Italian hate rate in this courtroom is disgusting.
Plaintiff attorney: Objection. His accent is really bringing it on himself.
Judge: Sustained. Watch it, Wario.
Defense attorney: You know, funny you should mention his accent. Your honor, I’d like to submit as evidence Wario’s Super Mario wiki fan page and this is all real.
Wario: People are so mean online.
Defense attorney: First, the section entitled ‘personality’ and see if this doesn’t sound defamatory to my client’s character. “Wario is generally lazy, ruthless and greedy. He is foul and smelly, as he eats a lot of garlic, his favorite food.” Wow! Racist much?
Plaintiff attorney: Objection! He is eating garlic right now.
Defense attorney: Let’s just keep reading. Shall we? Here’s a section titled ‘friends’. “Wario has almost never been seen with friends. The only person who hangs out with him is Waluigi, the evil Luigi.”
Waluigi: And I don’t appreciate that description. I Waluigi. It’s like a weird Luigi. Not an evil Luigi. Not at all.
Plaintiff attorney: Objection, how is any of this relevant?
Defense attorney: It goes toward how my client is unfairly painted as a villain. Listen to his theme song.[Wario’s theme songs plays. He starts dancing.]
Judge: Alright. I’ll have order in this court.
Defense attorney: Wario, you know Mario better than anyone.
Wario: He’s just like me, only different colors. And I’m a little fatter.
Defense attorney: Did Mario have a dark side?
Wario: Yes. He started eating mushrooms. At first it was micro-dosing. And then it became macro-dosing. And sometimes he was flashing like he was invincible. That’s when he was on cocaine.
Plaintiff attorney: Objection.
Judge: Overruled. This is fun.
Defense attorney: And was there anything off between him and Luigi?
Wario: Yes. I hate for it to come out like this but Luigi was sleeping with Princess Peach, Mario’s wife.[Luigi and Princess Peach get angry]
Luigi: You lie. We never sleep together.
Princess Peach: I never touch him under the overall.
Defense attorney: Hah! If what you say is true, how do you explain these text messages. “Hey Luigi, my faucet’s dripping. I need a plumber who can really lay some pipe.” From Luigi, three:seventeen AM, “U up? I am…” And then he sent this video.[The video shows Luigi’s penis getting an erection. The sound of Mario’s growing plays.]
Defense attorney: And I don’t think I need to tell you what the growing noise means.
Luigi: You are son of a bitch. Your ruin my life![Luigi pulls out a turtle]
Princess Peach: Luigi, no!
Judge: He’s got a red turtle shell.[Andrew Cuomo walks in]
Andrew Cuomo: Hello. I’m governor Andrew Cuomo.
Wario: And I’m Wario.
Andrew Cuomo: And we are two misunderstood Italian Americans.
Wario: I’m actually Japanese, but okay.
Andrew Cuomo: Sure. Please don’t believe the horrible stereotypes. You see, in Mario world, some of the bad guys are even called “Goombas”.[Mario walks in]
Mario: And I’m regular Mario. Don’t worry about me. Sure, I died. But I still got three lives left. [starts dancing]
Andrew Cuomo: And hopefully, so do I.[Cut to Italian-American Anti-Defamation League logo]
Male voice: This has been a message from Italian-American Anti-Defamation League
Cartoon Wario: Ane me, Wario! Ha-ha-ha-ha.